Custom Cookies for Every Celebration → Birthdays → Weddings → Baby Showers → Corporate Events → Graduations

My Cart

× Mint Cream 2 × $57.48
× Rasperry Linzer 1 × $57.48
× Orange Chocolate Chip 2 × $57.48
× Walnut Crescents 2 × $47.88
× Snickerdoodle 1 × $47.88
× Cranberry Pecan Shortbread 1 × $57.48
× Vanilla Birthday 1 × $47.88
× Vegan Coconut Chocolate Chip 1 × $57.48

Subtotal: $593.88

View cart Checkout

“Vegan Coconut Chocolate Chip” has been added to your cart. View cart

Old School Peanut Butter

Home

Shop

$47.88

Price for 12 Cookies

Classic peanut butter cookies topped with dark chocolate and chopped salted peanuts, baked fresh daily for a rich nostalgic bite.

• Price shown is for one box of 12 cookies
• Estimated delivery: 1–2 business days in Massachusetts (MA), and 1–3 business days in New England states (NH, RI, CT, VT, ME).
• Carefully packed with protective materials for shipping
• Perfect for gifting, gatherings & events

Description
Additional information

Allergens & Storage

Contains: Dairy, Peanuts, Eggs, Gluten

At Storybite, nothing is frozen and nothing is rushed just thoughtfully baked cookies made to be shared. No refrigeration required. Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and excessive heat.

Perfect for gatherings, gifting, celebrations, or simply enjoying with coffee.

Freshness	Baked Daily
Box Size	12 Cookies
Refrigeration	Not Required
Storage	Cool, Dry Place
Packaging	Protective Materials
Occasion	Gifting, Gatherings & Events

Price for 12 Cookies

Allergens & Storage

You May Also Like

Ginger Molasses

Chocolate Filled Macaroons

Coconut Fudgie

Walnut Crescents